Niles Trammell had a vision—a vision of “the formation of a television network radiating outward from Chicago that would include Milwaukee, Minneapolis, St. Paul, Des Moines, St. Louis, Indianapolis, and Cleveland,” as Larry Wolters of the Chicago Tribune put it.
Trammell was the president of NBC. His vision of a Midwestern network became a reality in fall 1948. Not too many days after that, NBC had its station in Cleveland.
On February 25, 1944, NBC applied for commercial TV stations in Cleveland, Channel 1; Chicago, Channel 1; Los Angeles, Channel 3; San Francisco, Channel 4 and Denver, Channel 2. Channel 1 was taken out of the TV band in an FCC reallocation on Nov. 21, 1945. At the same time, Cleveland was allotted Channels 2, 4, 5, 7 and 9.
The FCC acted on May 17, 1946, handing out a number of station construction permits. This story ran in the Cleveland Press the following day.
WTAM Gets Television Rights; Will Operate in Nine Months
By STANLEY ANDERSON
Cleveland may have an operating television station within nine months to one year. The Federal Communications Commission yesterday [17] granted the National Broadcasting Co., which owns and operates WTAM in this city, a license to erect a commercial television station here.
On the basis of its application to the FCC, WTAM would operate its television broadcasts in the 66 to 72- megacycle channel. Eddie Leonard, WTAM's chief engineer, said the proposed station would function with a 19-kilowatt effective radiated power which would be derived from five visual kilowatts and five oral kilowatts.
WTAM proposed in its application that its transmitter tower be constructed on the roof of its present standard radio studio quarters, the NBC Building on Superior Ave.
According to plans worked out by the WTAM engineering department the projected station would have a 30 to 43-mile coverage in this area. It would, for instance, reach Vermilion to the west (39 miles), North Perry to the east (43 miles), an area near Burton (33) miles and three towns to the south (Granger, Medina and Bath—34 miles). Canadian shores are too distant for average television coverage.
Asked last night when he thought the NBC station might telecast, Vernon Pribble, WTAM manager, said "It is all dependent upon the availability of materials and equipment, but we hope to be prepared within nine months to a year. Conditions may shorten or lengthen this time. For instance, we do not know what military equipment may be released for such purposes in the immediate future."
Network shows from New York will be available in this city only when a Philadelphia-Pittsburgh-Cleveland chain is established, according to present plans in the industry. This will involve the expensive and slow procedure of laying coaxial cables or erecting relay stations.
The NBC license is the first in this region to be granted.
“A year” was incredibly optimistic. There were the usual requests to the FCC for delays in the deadline to complete construction of the station.
The Cleveland Plain Dealer of March 19, 1947 reported on the quest to find physical home for the station.
WTAM TELEVISION MAY GO TO ARENA
Option on Studio Space Is Taken by Station
ROBERT S. STEPHAN
Radio Editor
Vernon H. Pribble, general manager of WTAM, now attending a meeting of National Broadcasting Co. executives in Atlanta, announced yesterday [18] that the Cleveland station had taken an option on space at the Cleveland Arena for its proposed television studios and for developments in the television field. At the same time Pribble verified the report that N. B. C. had filed an application with the Federal Communications Commission in Washington for authority to change WTAM's proposed television transmitter site from the top of the N. B C. Building here to WTAM's current transmitter site on Snowvine Road, Brecksville.
The Brecksville site, with its high elevation, half way between Cleveland and Akron, lends itself to the erection of an antenna which can broadcast to both cities.
The present WTAM 435-foot antenna mast will be rebuilt, if FCC permission for the change in site is granted, so that it will accommodate not only WTAM but also a frequency-modulation antenna and the television antenna. It would thus carry both vision and sound signals.
The design of the new antenna will in no way detract from the efficiency of the present WTAM 1,100-kilocycle broadcasting.
The television station will be known as WNBK. If the proposed site is approved, the station is expected to serve an area extending roughly from the Sheffield Lake on the west to North Perry on the east and as far south as Canton, Medina, Wooster, Ravenna and Alliance.
The WTAM transmitter building at Brecksville will house all transmitter equipment, including both FM and television. Special large-size transmission lines will be uses to carry the power from the transmitter equipment to the antenna. The maximum power from the television antenna will be over 40 kilowatts on the visual signal and over 20 kilowatts on the aural signal.
The WTAM move to house its television studios in Cleveland Arena may be a bid to televise sports and other top events which play in the Arena annually.
It took over a year for the Plain Dealer to offer a progress report. This went to press on May 20, 1948.
WNBK, Television Station, Is Being Built in Brecksville
BY ROBERT S. STEPHAN
Radio Editor
CONSTRUCTION OF WNBK, the Cleveland N. B. C. television station, is well under way at WTAM's transmitter site at Brecksville. Primarily, WNBK will serve both Cleveland and Akron. A special single antenna will serve four transmitters, WTAM's current AM radio signal, the signal for WTAM's coming FM station, WTAM-FM, the television video signal and the special sound signal for the tele-pictures.
Television transmitter equipment is already at Brecksville. The antenna has been designed and ordered. F. C. Everett, back in 1937 an engineer on the WTAM staff, is supervising construction. He built the N. B. C. tele-transmitters in New York and Washington and will supervise the N. B. C. tele-construction in Chicago. When Cecil S. Bidlach and Ross J. Plaisted, WTAM engineers now in New York, complete their studies, WTAM will have six of its own engineers ready to take over television operation here.
WNBK's studios will be with those of WTAM in the N. B. C. Building, 815 Superior Avenue N. E. With a 480-foot tower in a natural geographic position in Brecksville, WNBK will have the highest television tower in Ohio.
The current time table calls for WNBK and WTAM-FM, WTAM'S FM station, to go on the air simultaneously in the fall. By Christmas, WNBK is expected to be a part of N. B. C.'s rapidly growing television network.
Six days later, the Plain Dealer’s Stephan mentioned:
A MOVE is under way which might hold up construction on WNBK, N. B. C.'s television station here, according to a report from Washington. A petition signed by WGAB, WJW and the Cleveland Broadcasting Co. (which is building WERE-FM here), the report says, has been presented to the Federal Communications Commission asking that the FCC set aside an order of April 29, granting an application by N. B. C.-WTAM for an extension of time in which to complete construction on WNBK. The argument advanced is that WTAM-N. B. C. has not proceeded with construction with "due diligence." No official comment was forthcoming yesterday from WTAM or the petitioning groups, but I understand construction on WNBK at the WTAM transmitter site in Brecksville is continuing.
Continue it did, objections being ignored. The Plain Dealer of June 14, 1948 reported:
Sidney N. Strotz, N. B. C. vice-president in charge of television, reports that N. B. C.’s station WNBK here will be added to the N. B. C. television network by the middle of October. A Plain Dealer Bureau dispatch out of Akron report that coaxial cable laying trains next month will be operating between Cuyahoga Falls and New Castle, Pa., along the Pittsburgh-Cleveland route which will eventually join the N. B. C. Midwest and eastern tele-chains out of Chicago and Philadelphia.
Strotz was band in town about a month later. He told the Plain Dealer the station would “open as a strictly local station” until the network affiliation was ready. Two days earlier, Anderson of the Press wrote the hope was the station would be operating by Oct. 16. There seems to have been some urgency as reports from NBC talked about WNBK being the headquarters for the Midwest network’s election coverage on Nov. 2.
The station was able to begin testing, but there was a setback reported on Oct. 14 by Anderson of the Press.
WNBK, the local NBC video station, has been running test patterns periodically during the past 10 days. The resolution in these patterns was satisfactory and everybody in the outfit was pleased. According to a report early yesterday, WNBK hoped to run test programs, film and live, Saturday [16] or Monday [18]. But late yesterday a vital part of WNBK’s transmitter blew in a thousand different directions. Now the launching of test programs has been delayed for another week. The part destroyed by the gremlins (nobody knows how to spell it) is hard to get. But WNBK is that near its opening, at least.
Stephan of the Plain Dealer told readers the next day “WNBK, the city’s second telestation (N. B. C.), tentatively plans to be on the air Nov. 1 on Channel 4. You may catch some experimental programs before that date.”
Things looked to be organised on October 26, 1948. A sidebar on Stephan’s Plain Dealer column noted:
WNBK PREVIEW
As a “preview” to its opening Monday [1], WNBK, the new N. B. C. television station here operating on Channel 4, presents the first of a Sunday night series this Sunday evening at 9 called “Television Playhouse,” sponsored by Philco. These hour dramas are created especially for television. Paul Muni makes his television debut in Elmer Rice’s “Counselor at Law.” Pat Harrington, once at WTAM here, is a member of the cast. Bert Lytell is a host.
Anderson’s space in the Press the same day remarked:
Maybe you are one who likes Paul Muni, one of the best character actors in the business. Maybe, too, you are one who likes Elmer Rice, who, off and on, has been one of the best playwrights in the country. Sunday night over WNBK at 9, you will see and hear Muni in Rice's "Counsellor-at-Law."
This television drama will be the first in a series to be carried by the NBC video outlet in Cleveland. The series is called Television Playhouse and is sponsored by Philco. The producing troupe is made up of members of the Actor's Equity television group, with Bert Lytell as production supervisor.
Television Playhouse plays will be telecast here from kinescopic film. So far this type of transcription has not been too successful. If NBC does not come up with a superior method, Television Playhouse, along with other kinescopic shows, might just as well be relegated to the dusty shelves.
This dramatic series opens the day before WNBK opens officially—Nov. 1. There will be other test programs Sunday night. The station ran test programs last night, including a children’s show involving Bob Reed and Ralph Eckhart. The pictures were clear. Apparently WNBK has licked transmitter problems so often encountered in preliminary skirmishes.
I look forward to Sunday night's production of the Rice play. If the film affords a good reproduction, WNBK is off to a good start. It will be wonderful to hear and see Muni in my own living room.
The station’s studios made at least one live test. Entertainment columnist Winson French in the Press reported, without specifics, it may not have been all that appropriate.
Proceeding to other matters, Dwight Fiske appeared on a WNBK television show the other evening and on the same night John McCormick, whose interests in video are more than casual [the TV station's G.M.], wandered into Borselino's with Janet Garfield and Mrs. Alec Brown to find out how the boy had fared. As you may or may not know, there is no censorship on television, but there is apt to be at any moment now.
Dwight, not to be stopped by anything, had elected to sing the sad story of Stella, the little white mouse who could have been much, much better than she was. So John McCormick, chewing his nails, nervously took his party out into the night. Straight to the Harbor Inn.
Ellen Duffy, the mad shopping bag artist of Lakewood, was also on the air that night—showing the public how to whip up something snappy in leather in no longer than 15 minutes. Reminding me she has finally snagged a telephone and is listed under information.
“Preview Day” contained more than the much-publicised Philco show. There were no live test shows, but NBC kinescopes played for two hours and ten minutes.
SUNDAY, OCTOBER 31, 1948
8:00—Toscanini Film, Arturo Toscanini leads the NBC Symphony in Beethoven’s Ninth (NBC). 9:00—Philco Television Playhouse, “Counsellor at Law.” Cast: Paul Muni, Ann Thomas, Pat Harrington, Sam Bonnell, Neva Patterson, Alex Clark, Joan Wetmore, Annie Thomashefsky, Jack Hartley, Barrie Wanless, Elmer Brown. Host: Bert Lytell. Director: Fred Coe. (NBC). 10:00—NBC Newsreel (NBC).
The next day, Anderson reviewed the preview and some other programmes on the air in Cleveland that evening. Space prevents from transcribing all of it, but he expressed the belief that “your ballot can be a vote against injustice” and an NBC radio show “effectively attacked domestic dictatorships and reminded us that voters win only by political action.” We’ll stick to his portion about WNBK’s evening.
As I write this, two nights before one of the most important elections in American history, I sit within the security and the comfort of my home. The youngsters have just thrown their good-night kisses. On the television screen a great man is conducting a great orchestra in a great composer's great music. (I know there are synonyms for "great," but I repeat it purposively.) Toscanini and the NBC Symphony are presenting Beethoven's Ninth Symphony on film. The film's sound drags much of the time, but I am concerned with the free spirit of Beethoven and Toscanini—the creator and the interpreter. Beethoven erased Napoleon Bonaparte's name from the title page of his "Eroica" symphony, when his sense of justice resented the Corsican's imperialistic motives.
Toscanini, who approaches Beethoven with moving reverence, once jeopardized his “security and comfort" by thumbing his nose at the Fascist leaders of his country. Even though the WNBK film did not quite come off technically last night, I felt that here was a meeting of artistic minds, even though Beethoven was born in 1770.
Beethoven and Toscanini represent something we must regard when we enter the voting booths tomorrow. They represent a resentment against boss-ism, when we think in local terms, and against jingoism, when we think in international terms.
"Justice" is the word which might best describe the thinking of a Beethoven or a Toscanini, or any free artistic soul. An artist has a free spirit when he is, first of all, a decent human being—and that means "Justice." . . .
Later in the evening WNBK produced Elmer Rice's "Counsellor-at-Law." Here, too, were traces of a social outlook, but Rice. . .did not write a play demanding that sheltered legislators institute reforms in an order. There is no justice if you and I do not vote.
As for the “official” first night of programming on November 1, 1948, the Plain Dealer’s Stephan, now dubbed “Radio-Television Editor,” gave his opinion.
WNBK was sending strong, clear picture signals over my screen Monday night. The sound introductions for the station's various features on its official opening night were smooth, too. The cameras should have placed more emphasis upon closeup shots in the presentation of Ed Wallace's "How to Vote" sequence. The "middle distance" technique is still too tough for the telecamera. The best closeup definition comes with head-and-shoulder takes giving such shots variety by shooting from several angles.
But telesignals were really getting out Monday night. With its antenna pointed in the opposite direction, my receiver was bringing in a hockey game out of Detroit so clearly the numbers on the players' uniforms could be seen. That's remarkable.
One of the film shorts WNBK was showing Monday night presented Verle Mills, former WTAM and Cleveland Orchestra harpist.
The station had an unenviable task on its second night of programming—being the headquarters of the NBC Midwest network’s Election Night broadcast. The Plain Dealer reported the day before on what both Cleveland stations would be doing.
All Radio’s Facilities to Be in High Gear Election Night
BY ROBERT N. STEPHAN
Radio-Television Editor
TOMORROW NIGHT, whether you time in your radio or television receiver, your living room will be jammed with statistics and comment on the elections. Gone will be the Bob Hopes, the Fibber McGee, and the boxing bouts. This will be a night for the Heatters and Kaltenborns.The chains have made the usual elaborate coverage plans and all these network efforts are sponsored. Three of the new telecircuits, N B C., A. B. C. and C. B. S. have sponsors. Dumont also televises the elections.
IN CLEVELAND, televiewers will find WNBK, on Channel 4, the new N. B. C. telestation, taking an official bow tomorrow night by serving at the “anchor nation” for the election activities of the N. B. C. Midwest chain. Bill Ray, veteran news and special events manager of N. B. C.’s central division and Ted Mills, the division’s program head, are here from Chicago working with the WNBK group. Commentators they will have at their disposal will include WTAM’s Ed Wallace, Alex Dreier of Chicago, Robert McCormick of Washington, Edwin J. Lebherz of Buffalo, Frank Eschen of St. Louis and Harold True of Detroit. An elaborate setup of charts and maps in the WNBK studios at WTAM here will be used in telecasting the election results.
WEWS HERE will be carrying the A. B. C. Chain's Midwest televised election account. These telecasts will originate from Chicago against a similar background of charts and maps that WNBK will utilize in Cleveland. Commentators expected to be heard over the television hookup include George Hicks, Harrison Wood, Baukhage, Tris Coffin, Gordon Fraser and possibly Earl Godwin.
The Plain Dealer offered its review of WNBK’s coverage in its issue the following day.
Television Makes Election Epochal in City’s History
BY ROBERT S. STEPHAN
Radio-Television Editor
As this was being written last night, WNBK, the new N. B. C. television station, was making Cleveland history on its second official day on the air through Channel 4.
A staff of 50, under the supervision of William Ray, N. B. C.'s news chief from the chain's central division offices in Chicago, was originating in Cleveland and feeding to television stations in St. Louis, Detroit, Buffalo, Toledo and Chicago the first televised network report of a national election in the nation's history. It was estimated that some 500,000 were watching this telecast.
I was amazed at the clearness of the pictures as they paraded rows of figures, charts, maps and commentators in action across the screen. These pictures were as good as any I had ever seen in New York. The production was remarkably smooth and orderly. This telecast was a potent demonstration of the impact television will make in the home in the immediate future. This was a miracle come true.
The WNKB studio at WTAM was in precise order with its wall charts, for its commentators. One was struck by the youthfulness of the staff, but it knew its business. Batteries of kleig lights overhead had the workers prespiring. There was no smoking. Technicians and messengers ducked silently and hurriedly under cameras to keep out of focus as they took their positions. The work was done almost in silence.
Back in the control booth, which as warm as the studio, the telecast producer and engineers were in constant contact by head phones with the producers out in the studios. Saunders Thomas and Charles Panallo of Cleveland and Ted Mills of Chicago handled these assignments expertly.
WNBK was on the air around 7:45 last night and began its election broadcast sharply at 8.
No Hookup With East
WNBK, of course, had no hookup with N. B. C.'s eastern television chair and faced the problem of what to do when the outcome of the presidential race was clear. The station could not serve the Midwest with a picture of the winner. So it had made preparations to cut into its television circuit the regular N. B. C. radio sound coverage when the time came for the winner to address the nation.
Stephan had more in the Nov. 4 issue.
THE DIMENSION OF SIGHT gives television a terrific advantage over radio. This was again demonstrated most convincingly by the excellent election coverage by both the WNBK staff of N. B. C. workers here who fed the event to the N. B. C. Midwest chain and by the A. B. C. staff in Chicago whose efforts were viewed through WEWS here suplemented [sic] locally by WEWS' own coverage. The continuous coverage by both WNBK and WEWS, a matter of something over 10 consecutive hours, was a triumph of thoughtful planning. WEWS began its election story at 7:02 Tuesday night continuing to 5:29 yesterday morning. WNBK began its operation at 7:45 p. m., carrying through until 6:30 a. m. WNBK, with set only one previous day of official operation, lost its picture only once for seven minutes due to a mechanical mishap but continued its audio description uninterrupted.
WHEN I wearily shut off my telereceiver at 5 a. m., television still could not present the complete election picture. As early as 4 a. m., commentators on both WEWS and WNBK were seriously discussing the possibility that the outcome of the contest might eventually have to be decided in the House of Representatives.
The telecameras reveal physical fatigue. Over WNBK, for example commentators early in the evening were wearing coats and were observing a nonsmoking rule. But by 3 a. m., the coats were off, a cigarette or so had appeared, ties were askew and some of the lads were looking about for convenient places to rest. Similar fatigue signs marked the A. B. C. pictures out of Chicago through WEWS.
The WNBK technique of permitting viewers to watch a typewriter recording bulletin material was fascinating, but slowed up somewhat the speed in getting such bulletins to the viewer.
Televising also stresses manners. When Ed Wallace of WNBK brought Ohio's newly elected governor. Frank J. Lausche to the Midwest audience around 3:20 a. m. it was noticeable when Wallace neglected to present Ohio's new first lady, who was in the picture with her husband, until after Lausche had replied to several queries. WEWS also had Lausche before its cameras at 2:12 a. m.
TELEVISION ALSO brings the valuable opportunity of physical character study. Over WEWS, out of A. B. C. studios in Chicago, viewers saw closeups of the veteran and shrewd newspaper and radio commentators, Baukhage and Earl Godwin. Godwin revealed more personality than any other. As late as 3:35 yesterday morning, Godwin, despite the heat of the kleig lights in the A. B. C. Chicago studios, had refused to part with his coat.
Over WNBK, Alex Dreier of Chicago and Robert McCormick of Washington, revealed the most effective television stances. Around 4:25 yesterday morning, George Hicks in the A. B. C. Chicago studios, realizing that returns had been slowed almost to a standstill, remarked over WEWS that he thought it might be a good idea to go to bed. And at 5 a. m., when I dialed off, it was obvious over both WEWS and WNBK that it was getting to be a stern struggle to keep bulletins of interest moving. But it had been a great show, one destined to live in memory as a potent television "first."
No sooner did the station get praise for its election coverage that it stayed off the air the next three nights.
MONDAY, NOVEMBER 1, 1948
7:00—Test Pattern. 7:30—Why You Should Vote, live studio programme with Ed Wallace. 7:45—Film, “Musical Miniatures.” 8:00—Election Preview, studio programme. 8:30—Film, “Americana” (NBC).
TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 2, 1948
7:00—Test Pattern. 8:00—Election Coverage to completion.
WEDNESDAY, NOVEMBER 3, 1948
No programming.
THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 4, 1948
No programming.
FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 5, 1948
No programming.
SATURDAY, NOVEMBER 6, 1948
6:30—Test Pattern. 7:30—Football scores. 7:50—News. 8:00—Rowena the Minstrel Girl, folk songs by Rowena Frehse, zither player.
8:20—“Romantic Old Mexico.”
8:30—Man About Town
8:45—Film.
SUNDAY, NOVEMBER 7, 1948
7:30—Test Pattern. 8:30—Golden Wedding Day. 9:00—Philco Television Playhouse, “Angel in the Wings,” the first complete production of a hit Broadway musical revue ever brought to television, with Paul and Grace Hartman, Hank Ladd and host Bert Lytell (NBC). 10:00—Sign off. “Golden Wedding Day.” Charles A. Otis interviews Mr. and Mrs. William Nickels, 2055 W. 38th Street, marking their 54th wedding anniversary. Nill Boehm (Alphine Village), Maureen McNally and Marietta Richards will appear. (Plain Dealer).


























